A report on reporters-I
Last year March 27 was undoubtedly a tragic day in Sialkot when Zeeshan Butt, a local journalist working for a Lahore-based newspaper (Nawa-e-Waqt), was on phone. He was talking to the Sialkot District Council Chairperson Hina Arshad Warraich and complaining about death threats hurled on him by a PML-N backed Union Council Chairman Imran Cheema.
Zeeshan complained he had visited Imran’s office in Sambrial tehsil and questioned the recently introduced taxes on shops in Bhegowala bazar. Instead of giving the answer the journalist had sought, the UC chairman abused him and gave death threats. He wanted the issue to be hushed up and not brought to the notice of high-ups.
While Zeeshan was in the middle of the phone call, Imran appeared on the spot with his accomplices and fired shots at Zeeshan. The deafening noise of the shots was followed by a pin drop silence. The victim fell to the ground and succumbed to the fatal injuries.
These details were not narrated by any eye witness or aide of Zeeshan. In fact, these were all recorded and recovered from his cell phone taken into custody by the police. Even the sound of the shots fired at him were recorded and heard by countless people who had access to this audio circulated widely on social media.
Soon afterward, it became an issue about threats to media and freedom of expression. Voices emerged from all over to bring the culprits to justice. Journalists from the entire country built up pressure on the concerned quarters to arrest and punish the culprits. However, at the same time, anti-narrative was flared up too, propagating that it was a result of personal enmity and not the other way around.
Reportedly, there were repeated attempts to spread this perception because the police was finding it hard to sustain the pressure from the journalist fraternity. Meanwhile, it was a pity that hardly any media organisation mentioned the name of Zeeshan’s organisation while carrying follow-up reports about his murder and investigations. The main accused, Imran, has escaped abroad. The Supreme Court of Pakistan (SCP) took up the case and ordered the police to arrest the murderer as early as possible. Police arrested Usman alias Sheeshu, Shahid, son of Arif, and Saqlain alias Maula while the main killer Imran Aslam Cheema escaped from the country and is not yet arrested.
Mazhar Abbas, former secretary general Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ), believes there are several reasons for the lack of progress and convictions in the cases of journalists’ murders. The foremost is the general inability of the heirs to follow up these cases and go through the long process starting from registration of FIR to investigation, trial in sessions courts and hearing of appeals in the high court and the Supreme Court. In many cases, they do not have enough financial resources to hire lawyers and spend at police stations. So, if the family decides not to pursue the case or drop it any stage it cannot proceed. Police is reluctant to provide copy of the FIR and President of PFUJ says PFUJ doesn’t have any record of the slain journalist Saleem Shahzad’s family. No one is ready to talk on the issue.
The second reason is the missing support that should have come from their organisations. A majority of the slain journalists in Punjab, he says, “were found to be affiliated with small organisations and based away from big urban centres”. The journalist unions, he says, “do raise voice but these are the media organisations which must own their workers and pursue the cases.”
This is just one case in point and reflects the general trend in the Punjab province. Here journalists are mostly threatened, harassed and killed by influentials who are annoyed by exposition of their wrongdoings. A quick glance at the incidents of journalists’ murders in Punjab shows most of them were district/tehsil correspondents of media organisations who had tried to expose the influential politicians, criminals, gangsters etc. There are others, too, who died due to excesses by invisible forces or terrorism in Punjab, but their numbers are very few.
However, regardless of the type, one finds that the fate of these cases is similar. From reporting to investigation and prosecution, award of financial compensation to the heirs, role of the employers, there is a strange resemblance with the extraordinary happening in a few cases.
To start with, one can discuss the cases of Saleem Shahzad, whose body was recovered from a canal in Mandi Bahauddin, and Ejaz ul Haq, an employee of City 42, shot dead by Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) terrorists in Lahore.
Saleem Shahzad worked for Asia Times Online based in Hong Kong and Italian news agency Adnkronos (AKI) and was killed on May 10, 2011. Reportedly, he had been kidnapped from Islamabad while he was on his way to the office of a TV channel to take part in a talk show. The global rights body Human Rights Watch claimed Saleem had informed them about threats received from the country’s premier intelligence agency as he had been writing sensitive stories not acceptable to it. This could not be proved during investigations as well as by the judicial commission formed for this purpose. Though, the commission did not clearly identify the culprit, it came out with suggestions on how to avert similar incidents and proposed monetary compensation for Saleem’s family, employment for his wife, and state-funded education for his children.
I contacted Zubair Akhtar, the Station House Officer (SHO) of Sadar Mandi Bahauddin Police Station to get an update on the case. The SHO informed that the case had been closed because of lack of evidences. He was also not aware of the current status of the case and could not recall anybody from the family approaching him for this purpose. The SHO seemed to be in a hurry to end the call and denied having knowledge of the whereabouts of Saleem’s family. (You can get the contact details from FIR or PFUJ, please talk to them). Police is reluctant to provide copy of the FIR and President of PFUJ Rehman Bhutta says PFUJ doesn’t have any record of the slain journalist’s family. No one is ready to talk on the issue.
Saleem Shahzad’s wife, Anita Saleem, has given an interview to AKI which appeared on November 29, 2018. In the interview, she disclosed, the family has not received any support from the government or any other source. She said, “We will never know who killed Saleem, and why.”
On May 28, 2010, during a terrorist attack on Ahmadi community’s worship place in Garhi Shahu, a journalist Ijazul Haq was killed when he was giving live updates on his cellular phone to his TV Channel City 42. At least 98 people were killed on the spot and 120 got severely injured in this terrorist attack.
According to Amir, a technician in City 42, a colleague and friend of the slain journalist, Ijaz was very humble and a hardworking man. He said after his death, Mohsin Naqvi, the owner of City 42, extended financial help to the family. The family, residing in Lahore at that time, was given Rs 0.5 million by the PPP government which also announced free education for his children.
Another colleague of his who does not want to be named, revealed that the entire family left Pakistan and settled abroad. According to him, it was alleged that he was an Ahmadi and his family received support from the community and settled abroad.
Coming to the cases of journalists falling victims to enmities developed with individuals or groups, we take up a couple of cases for discussion and analyse them. For example, Amir Wakeel, correspondent of daily Awami Inqlab, was killed by unknown assailants in Rawalpindi on January 23, 2009. He left behind four kids who immediately moved to their ancestral area of Karak, KPK, after his death. His brother Kamal Asfar was an active journalist who had contested for National Assembly seat from Rawalpindi but disappeared from scene after pursuing his brother’s case for some time.
Abdul Waheed Anjum, Secretary Rawalpindi-Islamabad Press Club, says some journalists believe the brother of the slain journalist was also threatened by unknown men and warned not to pursue the case. Footprints of unknown killers were reportedly traced back in tribal areas of KP but not a single killer of Amir Wakeel has yet been arrested.
On January 23, 2009, afternoon, Amir Wakeel was killed at Committee Chowk in Rawalpindi by unknown killers. He was shot at and two bullets hit his head. He was shifted to District Head Quarter (DHQ) hospital Rawalpindi where he died.
Similarly, on April 22, 2014, Shahzad Iqbal, who was affiliated with Sama TV as a correspondent for six years in Mianwali district, was killed. Reportedly, the killers included Shafaullah Khan, Shabbir Khan and Irfan Khan. They shot fire at Shahzad and his brothers Sajjad Iqbal and Sikandar Iqbal when they were riding motorcycles. The assailants intercepted them in Nai Abadi Mianwali. All three of them received serious injuries and were shifted to District Hospital Mianwali where Shahzad was pronounced dead.
After one week, the killers were apprehended by police and presented before the court. The case continued for one and a half year. Later, the family settled the dispute with the accused and pardoned the murderers on May 26, 2016. Now, the accused are free. According to Sajjad Iqbal, the brother of the deceased, the organisation and Press Club Mianwali did not cooperate with the family. While defending the settlement, he explained that the family did not want to promote enmity. When inquired about the blood money in exchange of this pardon, he did not answer in affirmative. Sajjad was also injured seriously in the armed attack and this act of pardon appears quite unnatural. He was killed over an old enmity.
Muhammad Aftab Alam, a lawyer based in Islamabad, shares that the cases of journalists’ murders are taken like any other murder by the police and are not registered under any special law. Though a provision to invoke Article 7 of ATA has been taken and incorporated into substantial law, there is no supporting amendment in the procedural law that defines procedures to implement laws and award punishments.
Aftab believes that murder of a journalist is homicide as well as a curb on freedom of expression which is a constitutional right. Therefore, such cases must be treated under special laws. At the moment, the cases stay unresolved because the heirs are the complainants and they have to get things moving in a highly non-cooperative environment. He says cases of homicide cannot proceed if complainants are not aware of the complexities of our criminal justice system.
buy generic tricor 200mg purchase fenofibrate for sale buy tricor generic
buy cheap tricor fenofibrate uk order fenofibrate for sale
cialis 10mg generic tadalafil 5mg usa real viagra pharmacy prescription
order cialis 10mg pills sildenafil 50mg price sildenafil pills 25mg
order minoxidil online cheap buy tadalafil 10mg without prescription erection pills
how to buy precose prandin 2mg brand order griseofulvin 250 mg generic
buy precose 50mg for sale buy micronase generic order griseofulvin 250 mg sale
buy minoxidil paypal cheap ed pills pills for ed
aspirin without prescription buy levofloxacin 500mg for sale purchase zovirax creams
aspirin uk generic zovirax zovirax us
order dipyridamole 100mg without prescription pravastatin for sale order generic pravachol 10mg
generic dipyridamole dipyridamole 100mg ca buy pravastatin generic
order melatonin for sale melatonin 3mg over the counter buy danocrine generic
order duphaston 10 mg online cheap jardiance 10mg pill generic empagliflozin
buy generic florinef for sale buy generic imodium buy cheap loperamide
buy fludrocortisone without prescription rabeprazole 10mg usa buy loperamide for sale
duphaston online order generic dydrogesterone 10 mg order empagliflozin 10mg online cheap
monograph cheap generic pletal 100mg pletal 100 mg without prescription
order prasugrel 10mg purchase dramamine online tolterodine ca
prasugrel 10 mg usa chlorpromazine 100mg ca cost detrol 2mg
monograph 600mg pills pletal 100mg cost cilostazol 100mg ca
ferrous 100 mg ca buy ascorbic acid pills for sale order betapace 40 mg generic
ferrous sulfate price order sotalol 40mg cheap betapace 40 mg
order mestinon 60 mg order maxalt for sale purchase maxalt pills
order enalapril for sale doxazosin for sale buy cheap generic duphalac
buy enalapril online buy bicalutamide 50 mg sale purchase duphalac sale
mestinon 60mg pills purchase feldene pills order rizatriptan 5mg pills
buy cheap generic latanoprost purchase latanoprost rivastigmine order
buy betahistine 16mg without prescription latanoprost usa buy benemid 500mg generic
betahistine 16mg without prescription purchase zovirax eye drops order probalan pills
order latanoprost generic zovirax medication cheap rivastigmine 3mg
order omeprazole 20mg sale singulair 5mg drug metoprolol oral
purchase omeprazole generic omeprazole order online brand metoprolol 100mg
buy generic premarin buy dostinex cheap buy sildenafil generic
order premarin sale sildenafil 25mg sildenafil 50mg price
order telmisartan pill telmisartan buy online molnunat 200 mg us
tadalafil 10mg us order tadalafil 10mg sale sildenafil overnight delivery
order telmisartan 80mg sale buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg for sale cost molnunat 200 mg
cheap cenforce cenforce 100mg pills order chloroquine online
order cenforce 50mg generic chloroquine oral order chloroquine generic
tadalafil 10mg price cialis next day delivery cost sildenafil 100mg
purchase provigil deltasone order online order deltasone 5mg online
omnicef us order lansoprazole 15mg sale buy lansoprazole 15mg pills
omnicef 300 mg uk order omnicef 300mg generic prevacid generic
brand provigil 200mg prednisone 20mg us cheap deltasone 5mg
accutane without prescription accutane drug purchase azithromycin sale
atorvastatin 40mg drug purchase lipitor pills order norvasc without prescription
isotretinoin tablet azithromycin 500mg without prescription buy azithromycin 500mg generic
atorvastatin 20mg canada order atorvastatin 20mg online cheap buy norvasc sale
azipro sale buy neurontin pill order neurontin 600mg pills
azipro 500mg oral cheap omnacortil without prescription gabapentin 600mg for sale
casino games vegas casino online buy lasix medication
buy protonix paypal order pantoprazole 20mg sale phenazopyridine 200 mg pills
protonix 40mg over the counter order pantoprazole 20mg generic order phenazopyridine sale
roulette free play for fun best online blackjack buy furosemide 40mg online
win real money online casino for free purchase albuterol generic how to get ventolin without a prescription
online blackjack with friends ventolin 2mg tablet ventolin 4mg uk
order amantadine generic buy avlosulfon pills order dapsone 100mg without prescription
order amantadine generic tenormin 50mg pills order dapsone 100 mg for sale
casino games win real money play slots online ivermectin otc
win real money online casino for free casino games online levothyroxine sale
free online poker games blackjack free order generic synthroid 75mcg
medrol drug buy methylprednisolone online order aristocort pills
order medrol online cheap methylprednisolone canada triamcinolone 4mg usa
clomid online buy azathioprine no prescription imuran pill
serophene cost azathioprine online order imuran for sale online
coversyl usa clarinex order order allegra 180mg pills
order vardenafil 20mg generic order levitra for sale buy tizanidine sale
buy perindopril sale coversum brand order fexofenadine 180mg online
buy phenytoin 100 mg generic oxytrol over the counter buy oxytrol paypal
dilantin over the counter buy generic cyclobenzaprine order oxybutynin 2.5mg online cheap
buy generic baclofen online toradol pill buy toradol no prescription
claritin uk claritin 10mg drug cost priligy
order claritin without prescription priligy 60mg us priligy 30mg usa
lioresal online buy order toradol toradol usa
purchase baclofen pills ketorolac us buy toradol online
buy generic glimepiride for sale buy amaryl 1mg generic etoricoxib 60mg cheap
lioresal tablet endep 10mg cheap toradol usa
glimepiride 1mg price order etoricoxib 120mg generic order etoricoxib generic
order alendronate pill alendronate for sale buy macrodantin 100mg online cheap
fosamax 70mg cheap colcrys price order generic furadantin
buy generic inderal online inderal without prescription brand clopidogrel
inderal without prescription buy cheap generic clopidogrel buy plavix online
buy generic nortriptyline nortriptyline 25 mg drug panadol 500 mg uk
purchase pamelor pill panadol for sale purchase paracetamol
xenical brand buy mesalamine 800mg pills buy diltiazem 180mg for sale
medex over the counter purchase medex buy generic metoclopramide 10mg
purchase orlistat buy diltiazem 180mg online diltiazem over the counter
coumadin 5mg pills buy paroxetine 20mg pill buy metoclopramide 10mg generic
pepcid 20mg uk cozaar for sale order prograf 5mg online
order azelastine 10ml sale buy generic irbesartan purchase avalide pills
azelastine brand astelin 10ml tablet oral irbesartan 300mg
famotidine ca buy losartan 25mg tacrolimus 5mg for sale
buy nexium capsules topiramate 200mg brand buy topiramate 200mg sale
order nexium 20mg order topiramate 100mg without prescription order topamax pills
zyloprim 300mg canada cheap crestor how to get rosuvastatin without a prescription
order generic zyloprim 300mg order rosuvastatin 20mg pills rosuvastatin over the counter
imitrex 50mg brand buy avodart without a prescription avodart medication
sumatriptan over the counter avodart 0.5mg brand order avodart pills
buy generic buspar online buy generic buspar over the counter buy amiodarone 200mg pill
buy ranitidine for sale buy celecoxib medication celebrex 200mg pill
buy buspar 5mg pills buy cordarone 100mg sale oral amiodarone 100mg
buy zantac 300mg generic ranitidine 300mg us buy celebrex pill
buy motilium 10mg generic coreg 6.25mg cost tetracycline canada
order tamsulosin for sale zofran 4mg pills purchase zocor generic
motilium 10mg without prescription buy domperidone medication purchase tetracycline for sale
oral tamsulosin flomax oral cost zocor 10mg
buy aldactone paypal order generic propecia 5mg cheap proscar 1mg
help me with my essay cheap research papers for sale pay for paper writing
purchase essay online order research papers write essay for money
buy generic aldactone over the counter propecia pills purchase finasteride without prescription
buy forcan cheap cheap ampicillin buy cipro pills for sale
buy aurogra 50mg generic aurogra tablet estradiol price
sildenafil oral oral estrace 2mg cost yasmin
diflucan 100mg tablet buy fluconazole generic buy ciprofloxacin 500mg without prescription
buy generic metronidazole 200mg buy cephalexin online buy generic cephalexin
buy lamotrigine medication order mebendazole generic buy nemazole pills
order lamotrigine 200mg generic buy minipress for sale oral vermox
cheap metronidazole 200mg flagyl 400mg drug order keflex online
oral cleocin cleocin 300mg uk fildena pill
brand retin gel tadalafil 10mg uk order avanafil 200mg sale
order retin cream tretinoin cream generic purchase stendra without prescription
cleocin 150mg without prescription cheap erythromycin 500mg buying ed pills online
oral nolvadex 10mg buy generic budesonide online order symbicort sale
buy tadacip for sale order voltaren 50mg without prescription buy indocin without prescription
tadalafil generic voltaren 50mg ca order indocin capsule
nolvadex 20mg cheap nolvadex 20mg brand buy cheap rhinocort
brand axetil buy ceftin 250mg sale buy robaxin online
lamisil pill free slot machine games casino slots gambling
cefuroxime order online ceftin 250mg sale robaxin 500mg over the counter
desyrel 100mg canada order sildenafil 100mg cost clindac a
buy lamisil lamisil uk online casino usa
buy desyrel paypal order desyrel sale buy generic clindac a online
aspirin 75 mg oral best online gambling sites online poker free
practice essay writing online homework helper online cefixime price
order an essay online essay writing service buy generic cefixime online
buy aspirin 75 mg generic aspirin 75 mg us casino free spin
write me a essay online casino real money no deposit casino games real money
order generic trimox order trimox online macrobid online
my future essay writing help with essays money slots
buy amoxicillin 500mg sale purchase anastrozole generic order biaxin 250mg generic
rocaltrol online order tricor for sale online order generic tricor 160mg
catapres pills order catapres 0.1mg online tiotropium bromide online buy
calcitriol 0.25mg for sale buy generic calcitriol purchase fenofibrate online
catapres 0.1 mg price clonidine order spiriva brand
acne medication prescribed by doctors best acne medication for men buy oxcarbazepine 300mg pills
oral minocin 100mg hytrin 1mg us how to get ropinirole without a prescription
best acne pills prescription oral trileptal 600mg order trileptal pills
purchase minomycin without prescription hytrin 1mg sale buy requip 2mg sale
how to get uroxatral without a prescription alfuzosin tablet strongest antacid over counter
cheap alfuzosin 10mg percription medicine for stomach cramps heartburn medication that works fast
buy femara 2.5 mg generic buy aripiprazole generic purchase abilify online cheap
buy sleeping pills online usa fda approved hair loss treatments online prescription weight loss programs
femara 2.5mg uk femara us abilify 20mg canada
prescription sleep drug list best ipl hair removal at home best online weight loss prescription
order provera pills praziquantel 600mg for sale buy hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg pills
medication becoming reliant on nicotine buy painkillers online usa pain drugs listed for strengthen
buy provera 5mg for sale praziquantel without prescription buy microzide generic
free medication to stop smoking nhs stop smoking clinic list of strongest pain medications
antiviral drugs names buy inhalers for asthma online once a day diabetic pill
cyproheptadine uk order luvox 50mg online buy generic ketoconazole 200 mg
buy generic cyproheptadine periactin 4mg canada order nizoral 200 mg generic
how do antiviral drugs work pills for herpes breakouts new drugs for diabetes 2023
pictures of fungus on skin lamisil for toenail fungus reviews top five blood pressure medications
buy cymbalta 20mg generic buy glipizide 10mg online cheap modafinil 200mg
generic duloxetine 40mg generic provigil 100mg modafinil 100mg without prescription
best supplements for fungus blood pressure medications dosage chart high blood pressure medication list names
duodenitis diet mayo clinic bacterial infection in bladder women gram negative bacilli antibiotics uti
buy promethazine online promethazine canada stromectol 3mg online
promethazine us stromectol 3mg usa buy ivermectin canada
can pateints withpud use acitaminophen pain relief for uti symptoms does macrobid cover gram negative rods
I’d must verify with you here. Which isn’t something I often do! I enjoy reading a post that will make people think. Additionally, thanks for allowing me to comment!
deltasone 10mg over the counter accutane 40mg drug amoxil 1000mg usa
buy deltasone 20mg buy accutane 40mg sale amoxicillin 250mg over the counter
emergency contraception pill near me medications that shrink the prostate stopping premature ekaculation medication
h2 blockers medication list how to reduce flatulence uk best home remedy for flatulence
order zithromax generic buy generic azithromycin online cost gabapentin 600mg
order azithromycin sale prednisolone 40mg cost buy neurontin without prescription
can vitamins cause indigestion scented fart pills bad smelling farts symptom of
order urso for sale brand ursodiol 300mg order cetirizine generic
order actigall generic zyban pill purchase cetirizine for sale
buy atomoxetine buy zoloft pill sertraline 50mg oral
order lasix online order ventolin 4mg inhaler buy antihistamine pills onlin
buy generic atomoxetine over the counter buy zoloft 100mg buy zoloft 100mg online cheap
purchase furosemide without prescription albuterol buy online albuterol order online
lexapro for sale fluoxetine online order revia 50mg without prescription
order lexapro 10mg generic order naltrexone 50 mg pill buy revia 50 mg pill
buy clavulanate paypal cost synthroid 150mcg order clomid without prescription
purchase augmentin pills levothroid pills buy clomid paypal