The noose and the internet | Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF)

Pakistan Press Foundation

The noose and the internet

Pakistan Press Foundation

IT was winter break at the University of Sindh, Jamshoro. The campus was largely empty, devoid of the usual students going to and from class. The women’s hostel, where female students who do not have family in town stay during the school year, was also largely empty. It was here that a young student named Naila Rind would meet her end.

According to police and media reports, Naila was found dead late on the evening of Sunday, Jan 1. She had returned from her village the day before to complete work on her Masters’ thesis that was due on Jan 15. In previous years, Naila had bagged a top position in the university exams. Her body was found suspended from a ceiling fan in one of the rooms of the hostel. In one more example of the callous disregard towards women, at least one Pakistani media channel obtained a video of the moments when the young woman’s body was recovered. Now available on the web, the intrusive and disrespectful video has received several views.

Cyberspace was not only the venue of the posthumous disregard of Naila; it may also have played a crucial role in pushing her to death’s door. One of the items seized by police after the body was discovered was her mobile phone. It is apparently based on data available on the phone that police were directed to the alleged involvement of a lecturer at a private university in Jamshoro, who allegedly befriended Naila on Facebook and pursued a relationship with her. According to the police, he refused to marry her and began instead to blackmail her. A number of text messages to him were found on Naila’s phone; he was also the last person she is said to have called prior to her death.

A few days after the young woman’s body was recovered, the police, that had declared the death a suicide, conducted a raid at the lecturer’s home and arrested him. The man, whose father is also a higher education official, has now been charged upon the complaint of Naila’s brother Nisar Rind. The family had always held that the case was not (as police initially held) a case of simple suicide. Naila had never had a history of depression nor were there any family problems that would have precipitated her making such a move.

Naila’s case reveals just how vulnerable Pakistani women are to cyber harassment and blackmail. In the past decade and a half, hundreds of men have taken to the internet to prey on unsuspecting women and girls. They then harass and blackmail them on the basis of information they gather. While the exact details of the lecturer’s relationship with Naila are not yet known, most of these incidents of cyber harassment follow a familiar pattern.

Men target women and girls, often gathering information about them, their family and their friends from social media websites. Once they zero in on a victim, they pretend to pursue a relationship, even marriage, all the while coaxing their victims into divulging information about themselves that could prove to be embarrassing, wheedling pictures out of them and involving them in intimate conversations and encounters. All of this material becomes the basis for their ultimate plan, which is extortion, blackmail and harassment.

Naila’s case reveals one set of facts via which harassers can hurt the young women of the country. In others I have heard, the harassing and blackmailing men are family members, husbands and cousins and relatives, who force women into compromising situations, make videos and pictures and then use those to ensure further compliance.

Pakistani society provides a particularly perfect ecosystem for cyber harassment. The internet is increasingly and widely available, offering both a window to the world and a place to ‘meet’ members of the opposite gender in a way that was previously impossible. Even as they are able to access the internet, few Pakistani women are aware of the dangers of sharing information online or that the men who may offer compliments can easily turn into abusers. Add to this the fact that social mores always and forever hold women responsible for all the ills of society and you have a perfect storm, where new technology meets archaic ideas about honour and women’s inferiority, tying a noose around the neck of all Pakistani women.

As is the case with issues such as workplace harassment and ‘honour’ killings, laws against cyber harassment do exist but they are rarely enforced, with culprits going largely unpunished.

As a letter written by Nighat Dad, who heads the Digital Rights Foundation, aptly summarised, the recent cybercrime bill fails women like Naila because it makes such crimes federal matters. The consequence of this is that local police in places like Jamshoro are ill informed and largely ignorant as to how cyber activity can play a crucial role in the harassment and death of women.

Glaring evidence of this, the letter notes, is the fact that the FIR lodged in Naila Rind’s case charges the accused under Section 9 and 13 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Ordinance of 2009. That law lapsed several years ago. The letter, addressed to the minister of information, begs the rules for the new (and recently passed) Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016 to be made public and to actually equip the cybercrime wing of the Federal Investigation Agency.

In the meantime, what the government has failed to do, the Digital Rights Foundation is trying to do. If you or anyone you know is a victim of cyber harassment, you can call the recently inaugurated Cyber Harassment Helpline; its number is 0800-393-93. Call the number and remember that the internet, like the rest of Pakistan, can be a dangerous place for women.

Dawn


144 Responses so far.

  1. Ksufvi says:

    tricor ca buy tricor 200mg fenofibrate 160mg price

  2. Tqmevt says:

    tricor 160mg generic how to buy tricor fenofibrate 160mg drug

  3. Ryfjba says:

    order cialis 10mg cheap sildenafil generic viagra 100mg usa

  4. Hmrdgf says:

    cialis next day sildenafil pills 25mg canadian viagra online pharmacy

  5. Pccbqt says:

    order zaditor 1mg pills purchase ketotifen generic buy imipramine 25mg online

  6. Vsbtng says:

    buy mintop sale order flomax 0.2mg online cheap ed pills online

  7. Tetjei says:

    how to buy mintop best ed pills online can i buy ed pills over the counter

  8. Gqjgfg says:

    acarbose 50mg without prescription glyburide uk generic fulvicin

  9. Yitmap says:

    brand aspirin buy hydroquinone no prescription order imiquad creams

  10. Telfop says:

    order aspirin 75mg pill order eukroma cream purchase imiquimod online cheap

  11. Qvdttz says:

    buy melatonin 3 mg for sale buy desogestrel 0.075mg without prescription danocrine tablet

  12. Xswsfj says:

    order duphaston sale order sitagliptin 100 mg order jardiance 10mg online cheap

  13. Hbdorl says:

    order duphaston without prescription dapagliflozin 10mg canada empagliflozin 25mg cheap

  14. Kgikpt says:

    buy generic fludrocortisone where to buy dulcolax without a prescription where can i buy imodium

  15. Waclfd says:

    order monograph 600 mg generic mebeverine 135 mg ca order pletal 100 mg generic

  16. Grrcbp says:

    oral monograph 600mg buy cilostazol 100mg buy pletal online

  17. Zgtlxu says:

    purchase prasugrel without prescription chlorpromazine 50 mg cheap detrol over the counter

  18. Tqwgpf says:

    buy mestinon 60 mg pills rizatriptan pills maxalt order online

  19. Vvifaq says:

    ferrous 100mg canada order ascorbic acid 500mg online cheap betapace 40 mg pill

  20. Ioxrne says:

    order mestinon sale maxalt 10mg sale rizatriptan 5mg canada

  21. Rdewtr says:

    brand xalatan capecitabine 500mg oral purchase rivastigmine generic

  22. Pseoie says:

    betahistine 16mg us haldol canada probenecid 500mg without prescription

  23. Vaunvt says:

    purchase premarin sildenafil 100mg generic order viagra 50mg pills

  24. Jgmxyg says:

    buy premarin 0.625mg for sale buy premarin without prescription order viagra pill

  25. Oxuelz says:

    buy omeprazole tablets cheap singulair lopressor tablet

  26. Enjuaq says:

    cialis 5mg without prescription tadalafil 20mg brand real viagra 100mg

  27. Croohw says:

    cialis mail order us order tadalafil without prescription sildenafil overnight

  28. Ngfjhe says:

    cenforce for sale order naprosyn 500mg sale order aralen 250mg for sale

  29. Afapre says:

    buy modafinil 100mg generic order promethazine 25mg pills deltasone brand

  30. Bqnagx says:

    modafinil oral order phenergan generic generic deltasone 40mg

  31. Rrlzcj says:

    buy omnicef paypal buy prevacid cheap order generic prevacid 15mg

  32. Uaygcr says:

    buy isotretinoin 10mg pills azithromycin buy online order zithromax 250mg

  33. Wsaqpn says:

    isotretinoin 10mg for sale amoxil over the counter order zithromax 500mg generic

  34. Sxkcao says:

    azithromycin 250mg price cheap neurontin tablets gabapentin 600mg tablet

  35. Odkrpx says:

    azipro 250mg brand neurontin cost buy generic gabapentin over the counter

  36. Iicmyk says:

    lipitor 20mg tablet order proventil 100 mcg generic order amlodipine 5mg for sale

  37. Ymjnqz says:

    online gambling sites best casino slots online purchase lasix sale

  38. Ffsvre says:

    real money games buy lasix 100mg pills lasix oral

  39. Jibpce says:

    slots casino albuterol 4mg over the counter albuterol online buy

  40. Uqtmls says:

    buy generic protonix over the counter buy pyridium phenazopyridine without prescription

  41. Qrqfbq says:

    live casino slots online real money casino online usa buy ventolin inhalator online

  42. Aqnrbx says:

    slot games no deposit casino ivermectin oral

  43. Anwxee says:

    casino online stromectol 12mg canada ivermectin price

  44. Tpikaz says:

    amantadine 100 mg without prescription avlosulfon tablet avlosulfon 100 mg oral

  45. Jwkqjf says:

    blackjack online real money cheap levothyroxine levoxyl cheap

  46. Zomnfo says:

    real money slot machines buy clavulanate for sale levothroid pill

  47. Vgsnmo says:

    clomiphene buy online order imdur for sale imuran for sale online

  48. Wtfgey says:

    clomid cheap buy clomid generic buy imuran 25mg sale

  49. Liloln says:

    medrol 4 mg over the counter order nifedipine 10mg for sale order triamcinolone sale

  50. Nevamw says:

    levitra 20mg brand tizanidine 2mg uk buy tizanidine tablets

  51. Igdeek says:

    buy vardenafil 20mg generic lanoxin 250mg for sale oral zanaflex

  52. Jqzpky says:

    order dilantin 100mg sale flexeril for sale online buy oxytrol for sale

  53. Qtlezp says:

    buy generic perindopril 4mg buy desloratadine generic allegra 180mg cost

  54. Hwvaii says:

    buy dilantin 100mg for sale ditropan 2.5mg uk buy oxybutynin generic

  55. Eifwnz says:

    order baclofen generic order lioresal online cheap generic toradol

  56. Kwdlnt says:

    order loratadine 10mg generic claritin 10mg without prescription priligy 60mg without prescription

  57. Byxagw says:

    baclofen 25mg uk order toradol online cheap generic ketorolac

  58. Fcgfln says:

    brand baclofen 10mg baclofen 25mg uk buy toradol online cheap

  59. Zwwymf says:

    buy fosamax 70mg pill nitrofurantoin buy online order macrodantin 100mg

  60. Fxogqy says:

    fosamax 70mg canada purchase alendronate sale macrodantin 100 mg ca

  61. Zwwmzc says:

    brand inderal order plavix online cheap buy plavix pill

  62. Fkleng says:

    propranolol sale buy inderal buy generic plavix

  63. Juutyi says:

    buy generic amaryl over the counter order cytotec generic purchase etoricoxib for sale

  64. Jbrozk says:

    nortriptyline 25 mg without prescription acetaminophen 500mg brand panadol 500 mg uk

  65. Djcqyc says:

    pamelor 25 mg for sale oral methotrexate 2.5mg acetaminophen 500mg over the counter

  66. Bwodwj says:

    buy warfarin 2mg generic paxil uk generic reglan

  67. Vhjcaq says:

    buy warfarin 5mg sale buy metoclopramide sale order metoclopramide 10mg generic

  68. Dugtsx says:

    purchase orlistat generic asacol 400mg without prescription diltiazem sale

  69. Uslimi says:

    cheap pepcid 40mg buy famotidine 40mg sale prograf 1mg pills

  70. Nsabwy says:

    oral azelastine 10ml irbesartan sale cost avapro 150mg

  71. Ishwsb says:

    esomeprazole buy online brand esomeprazole 40mg order topiramate online

  72. Bkibqj says:

    esomeprazole 40mg without prescription order esomeprazole 40mg without prescription topamax order

  73. Odwsdy says:

    purchase sumatriptan online buy sumatriptan generic order avodart 0.5mg pills

  74. Acyfdd says:

    sumatriptan 50mg cheap order levaquin online avodart 0.5mg pills

  75. Qqetio says:

    buy allopurinol for sale how to buy zyloprim order crestor 10mg without prescription

  76. Wliwkj says:

    zantac order online buy meloxicam 7.5mg generic celecoxib buy online

  77. Czgade says:

    order ranitidine 150mg pill cheap zantac order generic celecoxib 100mg

  78. Rnxeqg says:

    buspar over the counter buy ezetimibe cheap cordarone 200mg oral

  79. Wtfbsr says:

    buy flomax 0.4mg online order flomax online cheap generic simvastatin

  80. Aeuobq says:

    order tamsulosin 0.2mg for sale buy simvastatin without a prescription buy zocor generic

  81. Bozleh says:

    domperidone canada buy domperidone without a prescription tetracycline for sale

  82. Bykqwn says:

    spironolactone 25mg canada valacyclovir 1000mg cost proscar usa

  83. Ldigdc says:

    spironolactone 100mg brand buy generic valtrex order propecia 5mg online

  84. Qldntf says:

    essay writers online essays online to buy edit letter

  85. Ylhkwr says:

    order forcan without prescription buy forcan cipro 500mg generic

  86. Dazwae says:

    diflucan 100mg without prescription forcan online buy ciprofloxacin price

  87. Vzdpyx says:

    sildenafil 50mg tablet sildenafil in usa order generic estrace 2mg

  88. Lacmnh says:

    buy flagyl sale flagyl 400mg pills keflex 125mg pills

  89. Viqdos says:

    flagyl 200mg pill order bactrim 960mg sale buy cephalexin generic

  90. Lackga says:

    lamotrigine 200mg usa prazosin 1mg pill buy vermox 100mg online cheap

  91. Qqrzpt says:

    order generic cleocin 300mg buy sildenafil pills fildena 50mg cheap

  92. Rbvnyk says:

    cleocin pill where to buy cleocin without a prescription cheap erectile dysfunction pills

  93. Udxcht says:

    order generic retin cream buy tadalis 20mg avana order online

  94. Dkdbqq says:

    buy nolvadex online cheap purchase betahistine online cheap order symbicort for sale

  95. Smkibs says:

    tamoxifen 10mg over the counter symbicort price oral rhinocort

  96. Gozhzg says:

    order ceftin 250mg generic cheap careprost order methocarbamol pills

  97. Mqjcsc says:

    buy tadacip medication buy indomethacin 50mg generic buy indocin 50mg generic

  98. Aszejd says:

    purchase ceftin axetil for sale online robaxin medication

  99. Wggwie says:

    order trazodone 100mg clindac a over the counter where can i buy clindac a

  100. Psgguz says:

    buy desyrel no prescription purchase trazodone pill buy generic clindac a online

  101. Kiwwwa says:

    purchase lamisil generic recommended you read parx casino online

  102. Bwmyfu says:

    order generic aspirin purchase aspirin pills play online blackjack for real money

  103. Fetvhs says:

    order aspirin 75 mg generic casino slots online blackjack spins website

  104. Stdyhp says:

    buy assignments online card games real money casino online usa

  105. Spjnna says:

    help writing a paper cefixime drug brand suprax

  106. Tjxhbe says:

    buy rocaltrol 0.25 mg sale cost labetalol 100 mg fenofibrate 200mg brand

  107. Wtqbsa says:

    order amoxicillin 250mg pills purchase arimidex online cheap buy biaxin 500mg generic

  108. Annjee says:

    buy cheap calcitriol buy fenofibrate generic purchase fenofibrate sale

  109. Iuaurv says:

    best oral treatment for acne prescriptions for acne that work purchase oxcarbazepine online

  110. Iqpnrs says:

    buy clonidine medication purchase catapres generic buy spiriva 9 mcg pills

  111. Riurvg says:

    strongest non prescription acne treatment oxcarbazepine 600mg brand oral oxcarbazepine

  112. Lthidt says:

    order alfuzosin 10mg for sale best prescription medication for reflux strongest antacid over counter

  113. Hxonba says:

    order minocycline 100mg online cheap hytrin 5mg us ropinirole 2mg tablet

  114. Mbyspj says:

    uroxatral 10mg without prescription oral uroxatral 10mg immediate heartburn relief otc

  115. Kmjefv says:

    strongest sleeping pills for insomnia top 10 sleeping pills nz best diet pills from mexico

  116. Zdltqz says:

    buy sleeping tablets uk online weight pills that really work get prescription diet pills online

  117. Pzdleq says:

    where to buy femara without a prescription order femara 2.5mg online cheap aripiprazole 20mg pills

  118. Eurftm says:

    new pill to quit smoking cost of arthritis medication list of opioid medications

  119. Pbnpwl says:

    two nicotine patches at once best stimulants for nicotine withdrawal order pain medication online prescription

  120. Rfmcja says:

    buy medroxyprogesterone 5mg online medroxyprogesterone 5mg sale order hydrochlorothiazide 25mg

  121. Lcoqbc says:

    medication that kills a virus big blue pill for herpes diabetes type 2 medicine list

  122. Skhhwr says:

    antiviral drug examples top selling diabetes drugs 2023 nhs website type 2 diabetes

  123. Vdchzz says:

    buy periactin 4mg generic ketoconazole 200mg generic buy ketoconazole medication

  124. Vznzty says:

    fungus clear now reviews daily suppressive therapy for herpes blood pressure medication brand names

  125. Xdpext says:

    what kills skin fungus fast buying blood pressure medicine online high blood pressure medications list

  126. Fbfqsy says:

    buy cymbalta 20mg generic buy provigil 200mg pill order provigil 200mg

  127. Whczbd says:

    stomach ulcer medication by prescription stomach medicine 7 letters cost prescription medication male uti

  128. Rikkdh says:

    duodenal erosions treatment common bacteria found in uti best over counter uti medicine

  129. Xfbzls says:

    brand phenergan pills erectile dysfunction ivermectin 200mg

  130. Jbflrq says:

    birth control online without insurance is hims a legitimate pharmacy how to naturally last longer

  131. Nenvni says:

    birth control pills free online quick relief for prostate pain exercises to increase ejaculation time

  132. Mnzxww says:

    order prednisone 40mg pill accutane 20mg ca amoxicillin 250mg tablet

  133. Awmnei says:

    buy generic azithromycin online azithromycin 500mg pills gabapentin order online

  134. Jctxrh says:

    ursodiol cost buy bupropion 150 mg online cheap cetirizine 5mg tablet

  135. Mvsgfh says:

    purchase strattera online cheap buy seroquel 50mg online cheap zoloft online buy

  136. Uxdouz says:

    buy strattera 10mg for sale purchase zoloft buy sertraline 50mg generic

  137. Fdevxc says:

    buy lexapro 10mg without prescription prozac 20mg cost order revia 50mg without prescription

  138. Zdxgtm says:

    order furosemide 100mg pills purchase acticlate generic cheap ventolin inhalator

  139. Lcniua says:

    order escitalopram online order fluoxetine 20mg online cheap buy revia online