SC restrains media from airing public comments in sub judice matters
ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan on Thursday issued a verdict wherein the media has been restrained from airing public comments regarding sub judice matters.
“The oft-used term ‘media trial’ is a real phenomenon and cannot be allowed where the fate of sub judice matters is being decided on public forums as not only the minds of the public are being influenced, but also potentially the minds of the judges, lawyers and investigators, which would obviously tend to prejudice the sub judice matter,” says a 33-page verdict authored by Chief Justice of Pakistan Mian Saqib Nisar in a contempt case against anchorperson Arshad Sharif.
The ruling says that the journalist community and media at large is either misinformed or if not misinformed have silently tolerated such demeanour for so long that the internationally accepted standards for responsible journalism are so far from their line of sight that they fail to see its limits that they so carelessly and recklessly exceed without so much as a speck of remorse.
The court said that the freedom of speech and the right to information provided in Articles 19 and 19A of the Constitution are in no manner “unqualified rights” and may be made subject to regulation and reasonable restrictions. Therefore, while they are to be safeguarded, they cannot be used as a casual excuse to trample on other fundamental rights of another, particularly those which guarantee citizens the right to be dealt in accordance with law and the right to fair trial and due process enshrined in Articles 4 and 10A of the Constitution.
“Drawing assumptions, inferences and conclusions from evidence or the documents filed in a case and stepping into the shoes of a judge on broadcasted programmes may not only convict the accused in the eyes of the public regardless of whether he is ultimately exonerated by a court, but certain comments or opinions may be voiced which could potentially instill bias and prejudice in the minds of the judges, particularly to those who are dealing with the sub judice matter, thereby violating the fundamental rights under Articles 4 and 10A of the Constitution of the persons involved in such matter,” says the verdict.
At the heart of the debate is the need for a balance to be struck between freedom of expression and the administration of justice.
In the context of International law and Pakistan’s international commitments in this regard, lies the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) to which Pakistan is a signatory since 2008. While Article 19 of the ICCPR protects, inter alia, the right to hold opinions without interference, the right to freedom of expression and right to impart information.
“All licensees should be sent a notice/reminder of their basic ethics and objectives, standards and obligations under the Code of Conduct, particularly Clause 4(10) thereof, in that, editorial oversight should be observed prior to the airing of all programmes and any programme, the subject or content of which is found or deemed to be in violation of the Code of Conduct in its true letter and spirit, should not be aired by the licensee.”
The court says that while content based on extracts of court proceedings, police records and other sources are allowed to the extent that they are fair and correct, any news or discussions in programmes shall not be aired which are likely to jeopardise ongoing inquiries, investigations or trials.
In compliance with Clause 5 of the Code of Conduct, the court ordered that all licensees should strictly ensure that an effective delaying mechanism is in place for broadcasting live programmes to ensure stern compliance with the Code of Conduct and Articles 4, 10A and 204 of the Constitution, which talks about protect the rights of individuals as well as contempt of court.
“In compliance with Clause 17 of the Code of Conduct, an impartial and competent in-house Monitoring Committee shall be formed by each licensee, with intimation to PEMRA which shall be duty bound to ensure compliance of the Code of Conduct,” reads the ruling.
With regards to the Monitoring Committee, the court directs that licensees (TV channels) include (for each of its meetings) at least one practicing lawyer of at least five years or above practice, with adequate understanding of the law to advise the licensee regarding any potential violations of the Code of Conduct by programmes to be aired in the future.
In compliance with Clause 20 of the Code of Conduct, each licensee (TV channel) shall be required to hold regular trainings of its officers, employees, staff, anchors, representatives etc with regards to ensure compliance with the Code of Conduct with the schedule and agenda of these regular trainings to be intimated to PEMRA through the Monitoring Committee.
If any licensee is found to have violated or failed to observe the Code of Conduct in its true letter and spirit, particularly Clause 4 of thereof, and/or Articles 4, 10A and 204 of the Constitution, strict and immediate action should be taken against such licensee in accordance with Section 33 of the Ordinance.
The court also observed that the Supreme Court or any high court retains the power to take cognisance of the matter and shall exercise its contempt powers under Article 204 ibid where such court is of the opinion that it is appropriate in the facts and circumstances of the case for it to do so and the unconditional and unqualified apology tendered by Arshad Sharif is accepted in view of the fact that in our opinion it has been tendered sincerely and he has expressed remorse and regret promising not to repeat such reckless and irresponsible behaviour in the future.
Sharif is also warned to be extremely careful in the future, says the judgement.
At the heart of this sub judice rule lies the view that an essential element of fair trial is an impartial judiciary and one simply cannot turn a blind eye to the fact that comment on a sub judice matter in the media or any other widely circulated publication has at least the potential of having an indirect effect on the minds of the judges seized of a matter.
Although judges have the ability to ignore any irrelevant considerations while adjudicating a matter, the mere risk or danger of causing prejudice to a pending matter is sufficient for the law to step in to protect the right of the one being adversely affected. While public interest may at times require that information be provided regarding a certain case, strict guidelines with regards to such publication are necessary to be imposed so as to ensure that the fundamental rights of all persons are given equal weightage including the accused or those involved in such proceedings.
The verdict said that a balance therefore must be struck between the right to freedom of speech and information on one hand and the right to fair trial, to be dealt with in accordance with law and of due process on the other. No person must be deprived of his fundamental right to be tried by an impartial judiciary and unbiased judge and an objective and fair trial unless a certain allegation is proved against him strictly in accordance with the law.
While on one hand such programmes are allowed to be aired thereby protecting the freedom of speech and the right to information; the requirement that they ought to be aired in an informative and objective manner and that no content should be aired which tends to prejudice the determination by a court, tribunal or any other judicial or quasi-judicial forum, ensures that the right to fair trial, to be dealt with in accordance with law and of due process are duly safeguarded. In fact, the Code of Conduct aids the broadcast media and distribution services in compliance of their responsibility under the Code of Conduct by providing pragmatic measures to ensure that they stay within the permissible boundaries of freedom of speech prescribed in the law when it comes to reporting sub judice matters, says the verdict
The court said that the law in Pakistan by virtue of the Code of Conduct in fact places greater trust in its media and journalist community by trusting that they will provide objective information about pending proceedings while taking precautions that they do not pass subjective or prejudicial comments in such regard.
Related Story
Dawn: SC orders Pemra to ensure editorial monitoring of shows before they are aired
fenofibrate canada tricor price order fenofibrate generic
tricor pill tricor 200mg pill fenofibrate oral
buy tadalafil online viagra order online order viagra 50mg online cheap
cialis 5mg drug purchase viagra pills buy sildenafil 100mg generic
zaditor 1mg cheap buy zaditor 1 mg generic imipramine 25mg price
order ketotifen 1mg generic buy generic imipramine cost imipramine 75mg
buy generic minoxidil for sale where to buy ed pills online buy ed pills online
mintop cost buy tamsulosin 0.4mg online cheap buy ed pills uk
acarbose 25mg sale buy acarbose pills for sale fulvicin generic
acarbose 25mg price buy precose 50mg without prescription buy fulvicin 250 mg pills
buy aspirin 75 mg online cheap lquin pill buy generic imiquimod
buy aspirin 75mg pills imiquimod usa imiquimod price
dipyridamole 100mg without prescription buy plendil generic pravastatin uk
buy melatonin pills for sale buy cerazette for sale buy danocrine 100 mg online cheap
dipyridamole sale lopid medication order pravachol 10mg without prescription
buy meloset 3mg without prescription buy generic norethindrone danazol medication
duphaston 10mg pills jardiance 25mg usa jardiance order
buy generic duphaston order dydrogesterone online brand empagliflozin 25mg
florinef 100 mcg pill order generic aciphex loperamide 2mg cheap
buy fludrocortisone 100 mcg for sale buy rabeprazole cheap buy loperamide 2 mg online
monograph over the counter buy mebeverine 135mg for sale purchase pletal without prescription
buy monograph cheap order cilostazol 100mg without prescription cilostazol 100 mg oral
prasugrel 10 mg generic buy prasugrel 10 mg pill buy tolterodine 1mg sale
ferrous 100mg for sale order ascorbic acid 500mg buy sotalol generic
ferrous sulfate 100 mg tablet buy betapace 40mg sotalol 40mg pill
mestinon us feldene usa generic rizatriptan 5mg
mestinon 60mg canada oral maxalt 5mg order maxalt 5mg
vasotec 10mg usa buy enalapril sale buy generic lactulose
enalapril brand buy duphalac generic lactulose cost
latanoprost order buy capecitabine 500 mg buy rivastigmine cheap
buy cheap generic xalatan xeloda 500 mg canada rivastigmine 6mg price
betahistine 16 mg canada haldol online buy purchase probenecid generic
buy betahistine no prescription purchase zovirax for sale buy probenecid 500mg generic
premarin ca viagra 50mg ca sildenafil online order
order premarin generic buy cabergoline online sildenafil 50mg oral
prilosec 20mg ca buy prilosec online cheap order metoprolol sale
purchase prilosec pill buy lopressor generic how to buy lopressor
order micardis 20mg sale molnupiravir uk buy movfor no prescription
oral telmisartan buy cheap generic hydroxychloroquine buy molnupiravir 200 mg pill
over the counter cialis viagra 50mg over the counter order viagra 100mg online
order tadalafil 5mg without prescription sildenafil online order order viagra generic
purchase cenforce for sale buy naproxen sale buy chloroquine without prescription
order cenforce 50mg without prescription order aralen 250mg online aralen 250mg price
provigil 200mg drug deltasone 20mg cost prednisone order online
generic modafinil 200mg order modafinil generic deltasone for sale online
cefdinir without prescription order glucophage 500mg without prescription order prevacid online cheap
cefdinir usa buy glucophage 500mg online cheap lansoprazole drug
buy accutane 20mg online cheap buy amoxicillin 500mg without prescription order zithromax without prescription
accutane 40mg sale azithromycin sale buy zithromax 500mg for sale
azithromycin 500mg generic order azipro generic buy generic gabapentin over the counter
atorvastatin where to buy order amlodipine 10mg online amlodipine order
cost azithromycin 500mg buy prednisolone without prescription cheap neurontin online
free poker games red dog casino furosemide for sale
online slot games furosemide online purchase lasix generic
order pantoprazole 20mg online protonix 20mg ca order phenazopyridine sale
playing poker online for money acticlate generic buy albuterol generic
free blackjack us blackjack online albuterol 4mg inhaler
slot machine online blackjack for money ivermectin over the counter uk
free spins stromectol 6mg oral ivermectin drug
buy symmetrel generic atenolol 100mg canada buy avlosulfon 100mg generic
amantadine 100 mg without prescription purchase atenolol sale avlosulfon order
real money spins online live online blackjack levoxyl order
poker online real money buy amoxiclav online cheap levothroid tablets
buy clomid 100mg online purchase clomid sale order generic azathioprine
medrol tablet methylprednisolone 16 mg without prescription buy triamcinolone 10mg online
generic vardenafil 10mg vardenafil 10mg usa tizanidine 2mg usa
purchase coversum buy perindopril cheap allegra 180mg cheap
order dilantin sale phenytoin tablet oxybutynin ca
order generic dilantin 100mg ditropan over the counter oxytrol pills
baclofen pills order amitriptyline 10mg without prescription buy ketorolac generic
buy baclofen without a prescription order generic baclofen buy ketorolac paypal
buy loratadine paypal order generic altace 10mg buy dapoxetine 90mg online
buy claritin 10mg pill order generic altace 10mg priligy for sale online
lioresal price buy ozobax for sale toradol cost
order lioresal buy baclofen 10mg without prescription buy cheap ketorolac
fosamax price buy furadantin 100mg for sale buy nitrofurantoin medication
fosamax 70mg generic order colchicine pill buy nitrofurantoin 100 mg online
buy glimepiride no prescription glimepiride 1mg usa cost arcoxia 60mg
buy cheap generic inderal oral clopidogrel 75mg purchase clopidogrel pills
cheap inderal 10mg buy ibuprofen 400mg generic buy clopidogrel generic
brand amaryl 4mg order arcoxia 60mg arcoxia 60mg sale
buy generic pamelor for sale buy nortriptyline generic buy acetaminophen for sale
buy pamelor acetaminophen 500mg without prescription order acetaminophen 500mg generic
warfarin 5mg canada cost paxil 20mg purchase maxolon online cheap
generic coumadin order reglan 20mg how to buy reglan
cheap xenical order xenical pill buy diltiazem pills
orlistat 60mg drug cheap xenical 60mg order diltiazem sale
famotidine brand buy generic prograf online tacrolimus 1mg pill
purchase famotidine online cheap tacrolimus 1mg for sale buy tacrolimus 5mg generic
astelin oral buy azelastine generic irbesartan 150mg pills
buy astelin 10 ml online cheap zovirax pills avapro 150mg over the counter
order esomeprazole 20mg pill buy generic esomeprazole order topiramate 100mg without prescription
esomeprazole 20mg pills topamax 200mg price order topamax 100mg without prescription
sumatriptan 25mg cost imitrex online order avodart online buy
order allopurinol 100mg online cheap zyloprim purchase rosuvastatin without prescription
order sumatriptan 50mg generic avodart 0.5mg oral avodart 0.5mg over the counter
buy allopurinol for sale buy allopurinol 300mg pills buy crestor pill
purchase zantac generic buy mobic for sale celebrex 200mg ca
zantac pill zantac 300mg over the counter celecoxib pills
buy generic buspirone 10mg zetia 10mg price order cordarone generic
buy buspirone without a prescription purchase zetia generic cordarone tablet
buy motilium generic tetracycline cost buy tetracycline pill
order flomax 0.2mg without prescription oral flomax buy zocor pill
order domperidone 10mg online sumycin 500mg brand order sumycin 500mg online
buy spironolactone without prescription buy valtrex buy propecia 1mg online
where can i buy an essay write thesis write my essay help
buying an essay write my thesis help me write a research paper
buy generic diflucan over the counter diflucan 100mg cheap buy cipro generic
generic aurogra viagra sildenafil 50mg order estradiol 1mg pill
buy aurogra for sale order estrace 1mg online order estrace 1mg pill
cost flagyl 400mg cephalexin us keflex over the counter
order generic lamictal cheap lamictal 200mg order nemazole pills
lamotrigine us vermox 100mg canada nemazole ca
generic cleocin 150mg generic erythromycin 250mg oral fildena 100mg
brand cleocin buy erythromycin 500mg online buy ed pills fda
order generic retin cream buy retin cream without prescription order generic avanafil 200mg
buy tretinoin generic tadalafil 20mg tablet buy stendra no prescription
buy tamoxifen generic purchase rhinocort without prescription buy symbicort no prescription
tadacip 10mg usa tadacip pill indocin without prescription
tadalafil 20mg uk order cambia generic buy generic indocin 50mg
buy axetil sale buy ceftin medication purchase robaxin pills
order ceftin 500mg sale buy generic ceftin over the counter robaxin sale
purchase desyrel online clindamycin tubes generic clindamycin
buy desyrel 100mg without prescription cheap trazodone 100mg clindac a without prescription
terbinafine uk buy generic lamisil over the counter real money casino games
terbinafine 250mg sale buy lamisil 250mg generic play for real online casino games
aspirin 75mg brand online gambling sites best online casinos real money
aspirin 75mg oral online casinos real money no deposit free spins
helpwithassignment international essay writing competition buy generic suprax
buy an assignment suprax 200mg generic order suprax 200mg pill
buy essays for college paper assistance online casinos for usa players
cheap essay writer gamble online win real money gambling game
buy generic trimox cheap amoxicillin 500mg purchase biaxin generic
brand amoxicillin 500mg clarithromycin 250mg for sale buy biaxin 250mg generic
order generic rocaltrol 0.25mg brand rocaltrol 0.25 mg order tricor 160mg online
buy rocaltrol 0.25mg generic order fenofibrate 160mg generic tricor 200mg pill
catapres 0.1mg oral purchase antivert buy spiriva paypal
clonidine 0.1mg brand spiriva brand spiriva without prescription
acne treatment for teens dermatology best acne treatment teen boys cheap oxcarbazepine
how to clear adult acne dermatologist acne treatment pills buy trileptal 300mg sale
how to get minocin without a prescription buy minocin order ropinirole pill
buy uroxatral 10 mg without prescription nausea medication names lower abdominal pain prescription medication
cheap minocin how to get requip without a prescription requip 2mg sale
uroxatral where to buy piriton allergy tablets canada heartburn treatment over the counter
sleeping pills online order dutasteride for hair loss reviews prescription weight loss pills
sleeping pills by price semaglutide weight loss prescription online contrave vs ozempic for weight loss
buy generic femara online letrozole 2.5mg for sale order aripiprazole 20mg without prescription
femara 2.5 mg oral femara generic aripiprazole 20mg drug
buy drug to quit smoking arthritis pain killers that work types of pain medications list
best prescription to stop smoking best medication to stop smoking buying pain pills online
buy medroxyprogesterone 10mg generic biltricide 600 mg uk buy hydrochlorothiazide medication
buy provera without a prescription generic microzide buy hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg pills
pills for herpes outbreak buy antiviral drugs what works better than metformin
online doctor prescription valtrex daily antiviral medication for herpes drugs used to treat diabetes
cyproheptadine online buy luvox pills nizoral online order
fungus clear fix reviews stop taking blood pressure tablets 5 best blood pressure medications
buy cymbalta cymbalta 20mg usa cheap provigil 100mg
cymbalta 20mg pill oral provigil 100mg buy provigil 100mg pill
will stomach lining repair itself how to heal a stomach ulcer fast what happens if you pee in bleach
instant stomach relief for ulcer uti treatment online free uti treatment online scam
cost promethazine 25mg buy phenergan without prescription ivermectin pill cost
order phenergan pills fda approved over the counter ed pills ivermectin uk coronavirus
how much does the birth control patch cost antibtoics used for chroinc prostate does viagra cure premature ejactulation
emergency contraceptive pill online morning after pill free online semen pills for men
order deltasone 10mg sale buy generic prednisone amoxil 500mg pills
order deltasone 40mg generic buy prednisone 20mg pill amoxicillin 500mg generic
medication to neutralize stomach acid medications that stop vomiting drugs cause flatulance
most effective h2 blocker list of prescription heartburn medications prescription for gas and bloating
buy azithromycin 500mg for sale order neurontin 800mg sale gabapentin canada
cost zithromax 500mg cheap zithromax brand neurontin 100mg
buy ursodiol no prescription urso brand purchase cetirizine pill
cost urso cheap zyban cetirizine 5mg uk
buy strattera 10mg seroquel 100mg pills generic sertraline
buy atomoxetine online cheap order sertraline 50mg pill buy zoloft sale
cost lasix 40mg order doxycycline 200mg for sale albuterol pills
lasix 40mg pills albuterol tablet purchase albuterol for sale
order escitalopram 10mg pills order generic escitalopram 20mg buy revia sale
buy escitalopram cheap order sarafem generic order revia 50 mg generic