Cost cuts in media
ONE 24/7 news television channel has shut down. Many other news channels, big and small, are teetering on the brink: their advertising revenues have been falling for several months.
The keyword in the (electronic) media these days is ‘rightsizing’. From camerapersons to producers to programme hosts — everyone’s job is on the line. Bureau offices have been particularly vulnerable to the campaign to cut expenses with many shutting down, rendering hundreds without work.
The devastation caused by plunging government and commercial advertising is real and substantial, and not limited to news TV networks alone. After all those doomsday predictions made ever since the birth of free electronic media some two decades ago, the bubble, it appears, has finally burst.
TV channels were always destined for some correction, meaning that some of them were supposed to fizzle out post-boom, only the fittest among them surviving. But the crisis is not limited to the channels, of which the experts say Pakistan has too many.
The newspaper industry has its own demons to overcome. Watching resignedly as companies took a substantial portion of their media spend from their print to their digital platforms to reach out to their target markets, the good old trusted newspaper is faced with a mortal threat as incomes fall drastically.
Thus starved of resources, newspapers and magazines have shed pages and created redundancies of their own. Some are finding it hard to pay salaries to their retained employees, contributing to the unrest and the increasingly vocal protest among journalists and other workers in the industry.
Here, too, media accounts do not match. Job loss estimates in television and newspapers vary from one industry source to another. Afzal Butt, president of his faction of the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ), puts the number of employees who have lost their jobs in this latest wave somewhere between 300 and 500. He fears more bad news over the next several months if the “bleeding doesn’t stop”.
‘The government has cut its media spend by more than 70 per cent and companies by almost 50pc’, says a leading advertising agency owner
Much has been said about how the current crisis is linked with the ascent to the throne of Prime Minister Imran Khan, who emerged on top in the midst of a badly polarised media. However, some sombre, less emotional versions say the difficulties predate Prime Minister Khan.
What has happened is that the government decision to sharply slash media spend and its refusal to clear outstanding payments to TV channels and newspapers, on account of advertisements released by the previous PML-N administration, intensified the trouble.
Information Minister Chaudhry Fawad Hussain promised last week to clear the unpaid bills of the media houses to protect jobs, but it is not yet clear if the provincial governments also plan to make the outstanding payments to help ease financial pressures facing television networks, newspapers and magazines.
A leading advertising agency owner told this correspondent in Lahore that the government has cut its media spend by more than 70 per cent and companies by almost 50pc, agreeing with the minister that the previous government had been ‘very generous’ in financially supporting media organisations through its publicity campaigns.
“The government’s media spend started falling soon after the installation of the caretaker governments in Islamabad and the provinces in the run-up to the July elections. Commercial advertisers began cutting their expense on media campaigns soon after the new government came into power because of tax and economic policy uncertainty,” he says, requesting anonymity because of his business relations with the federal and Punjab governments.
Indeed, the federal and provincial governments, especially of Punjab and Sindh, have in recent years heavily spent their way into the list of top 10 print media advertisers along with commercial banks, telcos, real estate developers, FMCG firms, food companies, etc.
Industry sources claim that advertising spend of both federal and provincial governments contributed the lion’s share to the incomes of TV channels in the last few years, but its exact size is difficult to calculate.
“The government has actually subsidised news channels for several years by buying air time at a much higher rate — around three times higher than the rate charged by the channels from a private company for the same duration and slot. The majority of the channels are facing the present financial crunch because their revenues from government advertisements have suddenly vanished,” says a senior executive of another major advertising agency from Karachi, refusing to reveal his identity.
The total advertising spend is ‘assumed’ to have grown at a reasonable rate over the last few years but the market remains significantly small given the number of media sources claiming their share from the pie.
Aurora, a Dawn Media Group publication on marketing, which annually compiles advertising spend collected from multiple sources, estimates that the market size has grown by a little less than a third from Rs66.9 billion in FY2015 to Rs87.7bn in FY2017, with almost half of the total revenues flowing in the way of TV channels and less than a quarter in the way of newspapers. The rest is divided among radio, Out of Home (OOH), digital formats, etc.
The keyword in the (electronic) media these days is ‘rightsizing’. From camerapersons to producers to programme hosts — everyone’s job is on the line
Some Karachi-based advertising firm executives, however, believe that the combined media spend of government and the private sector has grown to Rs90.5bn during CY2017, not very far from the Aurora estimates. But they insist television’s share in the market stands at 66.4pc compared with the print media share of 10.7pc.
On the basis of their popularity among viewers, the top six channels grabbed 45pc of the total television advertising spend of Rs42bn in FY2017. ARY Digitaland Hum TV topped the industry with a 10pc share each followed by Geo News with eight per cent, Geo Entertainment with seven per cent, and Urdu1 and PTV Home with five per cent each. The rest left for scores of other channels to share between them.
Similarly, the top three newspapers captured 47pc of the total print advertising revenue of Rs20bn with Jang topping the list with 26pc share followed by Dawn with 12pc and The Express Tribune with nine per cent.
The information minister accused the previous government of using advertising as a ‘political tool’, saying the PTI administration will “bring a balance” in the (news) industry through a transparent, merit-based policy for future distribution of the government’s media campaigns. He has repeatedly said the government wasn’t interested in bailing out media outlets with taxpayers’ money.
Many news industry analysts argue that if the PML-N used government advertising to ‘bribe’ channels and newspapers, the PTI is employing the same tool to muzzle them.
“In recent months, we’ve seen the state and its different organs bring pressure on media owners… to put them on the mat. Public sector advertisement that contributes 22-23pc to the total media revenue is being used to impose the government’s own agenda on the media,” asserts Adnan Rehmat, an Islamabad-based media analyst.
“The proposal to replace the existing separate electronic and print regulators with a new body, Pakistan Media Regulatory Authority (PMRA), to regulate print, electronic and social media without consulting the owners and journalists is an attempt to control the content (produced by the news media). The pitch is being laid against the content producers,” he argues.
Seemi Naghmana, a professor of mass communication at the University of Karachi, agrees with him. But she says the present crisis was long overdue because of mushroom growth in the television industry.
“We’re still watching new TV channels being launched in spite of the financial crunch gripping the industry. Our economy isn’t strong enough to support such mushroom growth of TV channels. So when the crunch came in the wake of cuts in government advertisement, many started retrenching their employees to hedge against potential losses,” she elaborates.
A Karachi-based senior journalist blames media consumers for their unwillingness to pay for the content produced by the television they watch, and newspapers and magazines they read.
“Because media consumers aren’t ready to pay for the content, the owners have built organisations that mainly depend on government and commercial advertisement revenue for sustenance. Reliance on the government increases when the economy is not performing. This is a fragile business model. Little wonder if governments take advantage of this fragility to control the content produced and gag free expression,” he explains.
Whatever little fee consumers pay to watch more than 100 channels at home goes to the distributors instead of content producers. Similarly, up to 40pc of the cost of a newspaper is pocketed by hawkers-distributors and another 10-20pc is lost in bad debts and unrecovered costs. While the television industry gets nothing from distributors, newspapers recover only a small fraction of their cost from sales.
Further, there is a general agreement among media professionals that the rise of internet and emergence of new means for advertisers to reach their target audience has diverted advertisement from the conventional TV and print media. The size of the advertising spend has increased over the years, but so has the number of claimants. The competition for advertising income has increased sharply.
“Many competing channels and newspapers are ready to become an extension of government propaganda,” says the Karachi-based journalist. “And these media houses are ready to do the bidding of businesses prepared to pay for the content of [these businesses’] liking to protect and increase their market share.”
Some principles it seems remain unchanged, even when the ‘turmoil’ has taken away many jobs and left everyone else in the media insecure.Representatives of the Pakistan Broadcasters Association and the All Pakistan Newspapers Society were not available for comment.
purchase fenofibrate pill order fenofibrate pill buy fenofibrate 200mg online
fenofibrate pill buy fenofibrate for sale order tricor online cheap
zaditor 1 mg uk order sinequan online cheap buy imipramine 75mg sale
buy tadalafil 5mg for sale real viagra sites sildenafil online order
buy generic tadalafil 40mg order viagra 100mg online sildenafil india
precose pill generic glyburide 2.5mg order fulvicin 250 mg generic
buy generic minoxytop minoxidil cost best ed pills at gnc
minoxidil where to buy cialis 20 free samples of ed pills
buy aspirin 75mg without prescription aspirin 75mg brand imiquad canada
buy dipyridamole felodipine 10mg canada buy cheap pravastatin
meloset 3mg generic buy generic aygestin buy danocrine 100 mg pills
buy duphaston pills buy cheap generic duphaston buy jardiance pills for sale
fludrocortisone 100 mcg without prescription cost fludrocortisone 100 mcg imodium cost
order prasugrel pills tolterodine online tolterodine for sale
etodolac 600 mg tablet monograph 600 mg for sale pletal online buy
etodolac 600 mg oral order monograph 600 mg pletal 100 mg ca
buy ferrous generic order risedronate buy betapace 40 mg sale
pyridostigmine over the counter feldene 20mg sale maxalt without prescription
order pyridostigmine generic order mestinon generic order rizatriptan 5mg
buy generic enalapril over the counter purchase enalapril without prescription duphalac bottles
buy betahistine 16mg sale betahistine 16mg cheap benemid 500 mg ca
zovirax for sale online order capecitabine generic order generic exelon 3mg
buy latanoprost for sale buy generic xalatan order exelon 6mg
buy generic prilosec 10mg order singulair 5mg buy metoprolol 50mg for sale
premarin 600 mg us oral cabergoline 0.25mg viagra overnight shipping usa
buy telmisartan tablets telmisartan where to buy molnupiravir ca
buy tadalafil sale order sildenafil 100mg without prescription cheap sildenafil 50mg
oral cenforce 50mg buy naprosyn 500mg sale aralen 250mg canada
cialis 40mg pill sildenafil mail order brand sildenafil 50mg
cefdinir canada order cefdinir 300mg pills purchase lansoprazole online cheap
modafinil 200mg ca buy phenergan online cheap order prednisone 20mg pill
modafinil 100mg without prescription brand provigil brand prednisone
accutane cost amoxil 250mg canada zithromax over the counter
oral atorvastatin 10mg lipitor for sale online amlodipine uk
azithromycin 250mg oral omnacortil 5mg without prescription buy gabapentin medication
blackjack free online gambling purchase lasix pill
pantoprazole 20mg over the counter order pantoprazole 20mg generic pyridium 200 mg cost
real money slots free spins no deposit buy doxycycline tablets ventolin inhalator drug
amantadine 100mg oral amantadine over the counter buy dapsone 100mg without prescription
slots meaning generic stromectol for humans ivermectin 200 mcg
play roulette for free cheap levothroid sale buy levothyroxine tablets
cost methylprednisolone order adalat 30mg sale buy triamcinolone 10mg generic
serophene for sale online imdur sale buy imuran medication
order generic levitra 20mg buy vardenafil medication tizanidine 2mg canada
buy generic aceon 8mg perindopril sale fexofenadine without prescription
order phenytoin order ditropan 2.5mg online cheap cheap ditropan 5mg
buy claritin cheap priligy usa priligy 30mg us
oral baclofen 25mg toradol 10mg tablet toradol us
buy generic baclofen buy cheap ketorolac buy ketorolac online cheap
order glimepiride 4mg online etoricoxib oral arcoxia medication
fosamax 70mg us alendronate 70mg oral macrodantin 100 mg drug
buy cheap generic inderal cheap motrin cost clopidogrel 150mg
buy nortriptyline 25 mg generic methotrexate 2.5mg oral panadol order
nortriptyline pills buy panadol 500 mg online cheap acetaminophen 500mg price
buy xenical without prescription order orlistat without prescription diltiazem online buy
buy generic medex warfarin cost buy reglan 10mg
buy warfarin 2mg online cheap paxil oral purchase reglan generic
azelastine 10 ml price zovirax 400mg tablet purchase avapro online
buy generic famotidine order losartan for sale tacrolimus price
pepcid 40mg drug purchase pepcid pills prograf 5mg brand
buy generic nexium for sale order mirtazapine online buy topiramate 100mg generic
buy generic nexium for sale esomeprazole 40mg brand topamax buy online
zyloprim us buy clobetasol for sale buy rosuvastatin 20mg without prescription
order allopurinol generic buy generic rosuvastatin 20mg order rosuvastatin 20mg pill
order sumatriptan pills avodart 0.5mg pill order avodart for sale
purchase buspin online order cordarone 100mg pills amiodarone 100mg drug
buy zantac pill zantac pill buy generic celecoxib for sale
cost motilium cheap sumycin 500mg tetracycline 250mg ca
domperidone pills carvedilol 6.25mg brand sumycin 500mg brand
tamsulosin 0.4mg canada buy generic simvastatin zocor 20mg sale
college essay writing help order essays online research paper help online
buy aldactone 100mg pill proscar online purchase finpecia sale
sildenafil over the counter buy aurogra 100mg for sale buy generic estrace 1mg
buy diflucan 200mg pill ampicillin 250mg oral buy baycip pill
order lamotrigine 200mg generic prazosin pills vermox oral
flagyl 400mg canada buy septra generic buy cephalexin 125mg for sale
cleocin 300mg oral order cleocin 300mg sale oral sildenafil 100mg
tretinoin cream cheap buy avanafil no prescription avana 100mg drug
oral nolvadex 20mg order nolvadex 10mg generic symbicort for sale
tadacip 20mg for sale brand diclofenac 50mg buy indocin pills
order cefuroxime 250mg generic careprost price buy methocarbamol generic
lamisil 250mg price legit real money online casinos gambling addiction
order trazodone 100mg online buy suhagra 50mg sale purchase clindac a sale
aspirin where to buy casino games online casino arizona
write papers for me buy essays for college buy suprax no prescription
help with thesis all real money online casinos best online blackjack real money
brand trimox order arimidex 1mg sale purchase biaxin sale
calcitriol 0.25 mg pill order rocaltrol without prescription cheap tricor 160mg
buy calcitriol 0.25mg pills buy generic fenofibrate 160mg order tricor 160mg
acne medication names pills buy generic trileptal trileptal 600mg pill
order minocycline 50mg generic requip drug buy ropinirole 2mg pill
order uroxatral alfuzosin 10 mg brand anti acid medication prescription
femara 2.5 mg tablet albendazole 400 mg price aripiprazole online
diphenhydramine hcl nighttime sleep aid sleeping pills by price weight loss drug lowest price
generic medroxyprogesterone order medroxyprogesterone generic brand microzide
nicotine replacement therapy chewing tobacco is nicobloc fda approved can you buy naproxen over the counter uk
cyproheptadine cheap periactin online ketoconazole 200mg cost
valacyclovir how long to take names of antiviral medication list ozempic not covered by insurance
order cymbalta 40mg online glucotrol tablet provigil order
where to buy fungus clear how to discontinue losartan list of high blood medications
order promethazine pill order promethazine pills ivermectin uk buy
buy promethazine tablets buy generic promethazine 25mg purchase stromectol
cause of gastric erosioins names for generic stomach medication antiseptic for urinary tract infection
virtual birth control appointment virtual birth control prescription best medication for premature ejaculation
how to buy prednisone prednisone 20mg pill purchase amoxicillin
azithromycin 250mg cost order zithromax 500mg generic order neurontin pill
urso 150mg canada bupropion canada zyrtec 10mg uk
buy strattera 25mg sale zoloft over the counter zoloft order
buy generic furosemide for sale order acticlate for sale ventolin 4mg inhaler
buy escitalopram paypal cost escitalopram 20mg buy naltrexone 50 mg sale
purchase amoxiclav generic buy amoxiclav generic clomid 100mg for sale